Connoisseur’s Corner: Bolivar Coronas Gigantes (1995)

Bolivar Coronas Gigantes

98
Romeo y Julieta Churchill (1989)

From first glance, this cigar is lovely. The dark, brown colorado wrapper is still streaked with black oils. While the draw was a little firm at the start, as it warmed, the cigar opened up and burned perfectly. Notes of caramel and cocoa, and a strong spiciness on the finish remained down to the final inch. This cigar has years of life left. —Gordon Mott

94
Punch Royal Selection No. 11 (1995)

Unbanded and unassuming, this smallish smoke punches far above its weight. It’s only 5 5/8 inches long with a 46 ring gauge, downright diminutive by today’s standards, but it delivers considerable strength. It’s floral, with some buttercream, wisps of leather and a finish that’s as long as a Tolstoy novel. Such a shame it’s no longer made. —David Savona

93
Recollection Perfecto (1932)

A Depression-era clear Havana made in the United States with Cuban tobacco by Congress Cigar Co. Nearly a century has turned the cellophane a dark tint of amber. The cigar takes to flame immediately, starting with a surprising leathery snap. After a few rough spots, this box-pressed little perfecto settles into warm notes of nutmeg and cappuccino. —Gregory Mottola


CIGAR AFICIONADO NEWSLETTERS
Check out Cigar Aficionado's newsletters, bringing you our latest ratings & reviews, cigar news and our guide to the good life.