Legislation

FDA Commenting Period Ends Tomorrow

Jul 24, 2018 | By Blake Droesch
FDA Commenting Period Ends Tomorrow

Attention premium cigar lovers: You have until just before midnight tomorrow to tell the FDA exactly what you think about the onerous regulations it has enacted on the cigar industry. The deadline to submit a comment to the agency regarding its proposed regulations of the premium cigar industry is tomorrow, July 25 at 11:59 P.M. EDT.

(Click here to read Marvin R. Shanken’s blog and learn how to submit a comment of your own.)

In March, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration issued an advance notice of proposed rulemaking (ANPRM) seeking comments and scientific data on the health impact of premium cigars. According to the agency, the information submitted will be used to “inform regulatory actions” with respect to premium cigars.

Regulations.gov has tallied 9,579 comments pertaining to premium cigars, but the actual number of comments is likely much larger. Drew Newman, general counsel for J.C. Newman Cigar Co., believes the FDA has received about 25,000 comments from its Save Cigar City campaign alone.  

“We distributed around 140,000 pre-printed, pre-stamped FDA comment postcards to [cigar] retailers,” said Newman. “The post office sends us a bill for the postage for every comment postcard that is mailed to the FDA.  As of last week, we’ve been billed for 21,138 postcards that have been delivered to FDA...Additionally, there are 3,500 comments electronically submitted in FDA’s system that reference ‘J.C. Newman.’” 

Newman believes the discrepancy could be attributed to the week or so delay between when comments are submitted and when they are posted online for review. 

The 90-day commenting period was initially supposed to conclude on June 25, but the FDA decided to extend the deadline by 30 days at the beginning of June. 

FDA

More in Legislation

See all
Ireland Considering Generational Tobacco Ban

Ireland Considering Generational Tobacco Ban

While such a proposal has not been officially introduced in the country's parliament, the nation’s …

Jul 21, 2026
New York State Introduces Generational Tobacco Ban Bill

New York State Introduces Generational Tobacco Ban Bill

The proposed legislation seeks to make it illegal for any person born after December 31, 2007, to …

Jun 4, 2026
United Kingdom’s Generational Tobacco Ban Officially Becomes Law

United Kingdom’s Generational Tobacco Ban Officially Becomes Law

A drastic law prohibits anyone born after New Year’s Day, 2009 to buy tobacco.

May 1, 2026
D.C. Justice Rules For Premium Cigars—Again

D.C. Justice Rules For Premium Cigars—Again

Judge Mehta upholds previous order to vacate FDA Deeming Rule, another victory for the cigar industry.

Apr 16, 2026
U.K.’s Generational Tobacco Ban About To Become Law

U.K.’s Generational Tobacco Ban About To Become Law

Anti-tobacco legislation would ban anyone born after 2009 from purchasing cigars in the United …

Mar 18, 2026
An Update On Current Legislation Targeting The Cigar Industry

An Update On Current Legislation Targeting The Cigar Industry

It’s been a busy start to the year in terms of legislative initiatives that directly target the cigar …

Mar 13, 2026
CIGAR AFICIONADO NEWSLETTERS
Check out Cigar Aficionado's newsletters, bringing you our latest ratings & reviews, cigar news and our guide to the good life.